Court of Session
Glenfiddich Wind Ltd v Dorenell Windfarm Ltd
[2025] CSOH 62
Expert evidence unnecessarily complicated a windfarm lease dispute.
Scotland
Search cases
7 cases
Court of Session
Ruby Properties v James Alistair Watt
[2025] CSOH 61
An unreliable spreadsheet left the expert opinion without a sound factual basis.
Sheriff Appeal Court
Tracey McGill v RM Property and Facilities Solutions Limited
[2025] SAC (Civ) 7
General health-and-safety knowledge did not establish expertise in medical foreseeability.
Sheriff Court
David Adam v Moneybarn
[2025] SC DUM 6
The diagnosis of car engine problems has come a long way since the days when a weekly check and clean of sparkplugs was necessary. Car dashboards light up with an astonishing array of warning lights and car mechanics use computer…
Court of Session
Dale House Developments Ltd v Brian C Ronnie and Ryden LLP
[2024] CSOH 99
It’s fairly common for experts to be criticised for having exceeded their expertise, not so common for them to be regarded as ‘too expert’. In a recent case involving the valuation of a hotel by an independent expert surveyor the…
Court of Session (Outer House)
David Walker v Smith Anderson Packaging Limited
[2012] CSOH 001
Ergonomics — an uncomfortable seat in the box. Academy commentary on judicial observations about the quality of expert evidence.
Court of Session
Macdonald Estates Plc v National Car Parks
[2009] ScotCS CSIH_79A
Arbitration or Expert’s Determination