Armstrong & O’Connor v First York

[2005] EWCA Civ 277

Court of Appeal | 2005 · reported | England and Wales

Originally published in TEDR Volume 11 Issue 1 (publication date not recorded).

[2005] EWCA Civ 277 TEDR Volume 11 Issue 1

This case concerned two claimants who claimed that, whilst waiting at traffic lights in the centre of York, one of the Defendant’s buses collided with their car, and that they sustained back injuries as a result.

The single joint expert in the matter, a forensic motor vehicle engineer, gave evidence to the effect that the damage sustained to the claimants’ car was so minimal as to suggest that the collision had not in fact caused the car to move at all, let alone jolt sufficiently to cause back injury.

The claimants called no technical evidence to challenge the expert’s view and simply relied on their own evidence that the collision had happened and had caused them injury.

This full content of this article is available to TAE members.

Log in Become a TAE Member

Articles reflect the law and practice at the time of original publication, except where a dated update is shown. Subsequent developments may affect their relevance or accuracy. They are provided for general information and do not constitute legal or professional advice. Obtain appropriate advice on your particular circumstances. Full disclaimer.

← Browse all cases

Contact Us